Lot # 406: 1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes #349-3 John O'Brien - PSA GOOD 2 (MK)

Category: 19th Century

Starting Bid: $250.00

Bids: 9 (Bid History)

Time Left: Auction closed


I have one to sell!

Lot / Auction Closed




This lot is closed. Bidding is not allowed.

Item was in Auction "Summer, 2025 Premier Auction - Closes August 9",
which ran from 7/23/2025 10:00 PM to
8/9/2025 9:00 PM



This member of the "0" series subset took its posers outdoors and near a place where one could play real, actual baseball! O'Brien is one of the pleasing outdoor images of Brooklyn players, complete with a grassy knoll and cloth base along its left edge.

The PSA GOOD 2 (MK) grade is a tough pill to swallow, considering how terrific Jack looks when compared to almost any other N172 player. Its depth of focus and contrast sits head and shoulders above an average image. We can understand how the rounded corners, slanted left edge, and pencil mark on the reverse led to this grade, while also recognizing how its technical particulars will be trumped by superior eye appeal. The population report shows five examples graded, with just one at a higher score.

This card appears as #349-3's reference image on page 340 of the Old Judge book by Miller, Gonsowski, and Masson. Love of the Game is proud to offer several cards seen in their outstanding work of research and presentation as part of our 100+ N172 listings.

Views: 87