Lot # 383: 1952 Mother's Cookies PCL Near-Complete Set (63/64)

Category: 1949-Present

Starting Bid: $1,000.00

Bids: 6 (Bid History)

Time Left: Auction closed
Lot / Auction Closed




This lot is closed. Bidding is not allowed.

Item was in Auction "Fall, 2022 - 10th Anniversary Auction",
which ran from 11/6/2022 12:00 PM to
11/26/2022 9:00 PM



One of the most popular regional minor league card sets ever, the Mother's Cookies cards featured Pacific Coast League players.  Distributed only on the west coast, the colorful round-cornered cards were included in packages of cookies.  The cards vary slightly in size, but are approximately 2 13/16" x 3 1/2", and are typically susceptible to condition flaws due to chipping at the colorful edges and the thin stock on which they were printed.  The set does feature a number of variations as well as cards of Hall of Famers Mel Ott and Chuck Gordon, as well as ballplayer-turned-TV Star Chuck Connors.  Five of the cards in the set - #11 Bill MacCawley, #16 Bob Talbot, #29 Buddy Peterson, #37 Roy Welmaker, and #43 Joe Erautt - are considered scarce.

Presented here is a particularly high-grade set, missing just the ultra-scarce #43 Erautt card.  Assembled by former Baltimore Orioles broadcaster Ted Patterson, a collector notorious for seeking out higher-grade cards prior to the advent of third-party grading, the cards virtually all appear high-grade, though some possess minor technical flaws typically related to light chipping at the edges and corners, or faint toning on the reverse.  We selected one card - the key card of Chuck Connors - to be graded by PSA, and received the grade of VG-EX 4 (MK) due to light staining at the lower left, as as the reverse.  We subsequently submitted 13 additional cards to SGC, receiving the following assessments: SGC NM-MT 8 (5 cards): #5 Grace, #13 Haney, #17 Singleton, #32 Ott (HOF), #42 Lyons. SGC NM-MT+ 7.5 (2 cards): #33 Chapman, #45 Baker.  SGC NM 7 (3 cards): #25 O'Doul, #37 Welmaker, #58 Myers. SGC EX-MT+ 6.5 (3 cards): #6 Basinski, #9 Marshall, #19 Gordon (HOF).  The entire set breaks down as 6% NM-MT, 16% NM, 33% EX/MT, 29% EX, 11% VG/EX, 3% GOOD with 2% lesser.  Card #11 of MacCawley appears EX/MT, with #16 Talbot EX/MT, #29 Peterson FAIR.  Card #39 of Chuck Stevens has been autographed in blue Sharpie along the left edge, not authenticated by almost certainly signed personally for Patterson.  An outstanding nearly complete set of one of the most important minor league card issues ever produced. 63 cards total.

Views: 318


I have one to sell!