Few Hall of Famers in the N172 Old Judge issue could be considered "rare" (though there are some) but the cards of Hall of Fame manager Connie Mack are certainly among the more scarce. This example checklisted as #285-3 is one of three different poses of the tall thin catcher and has been graded Authentic by SGC due to rebacking. We believe that even if the card were not rebacked it would receive the same Authentic grade due to a slight trim and yet the card still exhibits strong eye appeal despite a variety of other noticeable condition flaws.